Difference between revisions of "A Game of Thrones-Chapter 33"

From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
Jump to: navigation, search
(updated infobox)
(Added terms and places referenced)
 
(23 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{Infobox Chapter AGoT
 
{{Infobox Chapter AGoT
| pov = [[Eddard Stark|Eddard]]  
+
| pov = [[Eddard Stark]]
 +
| place        = [[King's Landing]]
 
| title = Eddard VIII
 
| title = Eddard VIII
 
| page = 294 (US bantam HC)
 
| page = 294 (US bantam HC)
Line 10: Line 11:
 
}} __NOTOC__
 
}} __NOTOC__
  
 +
[[Eddard Stark|Ned]] and King [[Robert Baratheon|Robert]] argue over a plot to kill [[Daenerys Targaryen]]. When the [[small council]] also sides against him, Ned resigns in protest. As Ned prepares to return to [[Winterfell]], [[Petyr Baelish|Littlefinger]] arrives with news that he has identified the [[Chataya's brothel|brothel]] that [[Jon Arryn]] and [[Stannis Baratheon]] visited.
  
| align="center" | [[A Game of Thrones-Chapter 32|Arya 3]]  
+
== Synopsis ==
| align="center" | [[A_Game_of_Thrones-Chapter_33|Eddard 8]]  
+
[[File:Thomas Denmark council.jpg|thumb|300px|left|Robert Baratheon’s small council © FFG]]
| align="center" |  
+
|-
+
[[Eddard Stark|Ned]] is trying to dissuade King [[Robert Baratheon|Robert]] from sending men to kill [[Daenerys Targaryen]], now that [[Varys]] has received reports of her pregnancy. Robert wants every [[House Targaryen|Targaryen]] dead and grows very angry with Ned’s resistance. Ned insists that even if the report is true a lot can happen before the child is old enough to be a threat; the mother might miscarry, or the child might be born female or die in infancy. Ned also proclaims that he will only fear the [[Dothraki]] when they teach their horses to run on water.
| align="center" colspan="3" | POV Characters
+
 
|-
+
[[Renly Baratheon|Renly]] comments that it was a mistake to allow [[Viserys Targaryen|Viserys]] and Daenerys to live this long. Ned insists that mercy is never a mistake, pointing out that at the [[Battle of the Trident]] Ser [[Barristan Selmy]] slew a dozen friends of both Ned and Robert, yet Robert absolved him and appointed him [[Lord Commander of the Kingsguard]]. Robert insists that it is not the same; Ser Barristan was a knight of the [[Kingsguard]]. Ned counters that Daenerys is a 14-year-old girl and asks why they overthrew [[House Targaryen]] if not to end the murder of children. Robert growls that it was to put an end to Targaryens.
| align="center" | [[Arya Stark|Arya]]  
+
 
| align="center" |  
+
When Ned questions how a man who never feared [[Rhaegar Targaryen]] can tremble at the shadow of an unborn child, King Robert bellows that he has heard enough and asks for a vote. The other councilors all side with the king except for Ser Barristan who states that there is no honor in killing an enemy in his mother’s womb.
| align="center" | [[Catelyn Tully|Catelyn]]
+
 
|-
+
With the decision made, Robert turns to the topic of how best to carry out the assassination. Renly suggests that Ser [[Jorah Mormont]], who craves a royal pardon, might be of use. Varys reminds them all that Ser Jorah is unlikely to risk the punishment the Dothraki would inflict on the murderer of a ''[[khaleesi]]''. Instead, the eunuch proposes the alternative of [[poison]], such as the [[Tears of Lys]]; [[Khal]] [[Drogo]] need never know it was not a natural death.
| align="center" | [[Image:House Stark.PNG|50px|House Stark.PNG]]  
+
 
| align="center" | [[Image:House Stark.PNG|50px|House Stark.PNG]]  
+
The mention of the Tears of Lys seems to awaken Grand [[Maester]] [[Pycelle]] from his drowsiness and Robert denounces poison as a coward’s weapon. Ned remarks on the hypocrisy of debating an honorable way to assassinate a 14-year-old and declares that Robert should do the killing himself, the honorable way among the [[First Men]]. Robert is astounded when he realizes that Ned actually means what he has just said.
| align="center" | [[Image:House Tully.PNG|50px|House Tully.PNG]]
+
 
 +
[[File:Ours is the Fury Lukasz Jaskolski II.jpg|Ned removes his badge of office, declaring that he thought Robert was a better man. © FFG|thumb|350px|right]]
 +
 
 +
Ned refuses to participate further, declaring that Robert can do as he likes but that he will have no part of it. Robert declares that, as [[Hand of the King|Hand]], Ned will do as commanded or be replaced by a Hand who will. Ned wishes luck to his replacement and removes his badge of office, declaring that he thought Robert was a better man. As Ned marches away, the king calls after him that he will have Ned’s head on a spike if he ever sees him again. Before Ned has even left, the council resumes the discussion and Ned overhears Pycelle telling the others of a society of assassins in [[Braavos]] called the [[Faceless Men]]. Littlefinger counters that they can hire an army of [[Mercenary|sellswords]] for a fraction of the price.
 +
 
 +
Ned returns to the [[Tower of the Hand]] and summons [[Vayon Poole]] to discuss arrangements for their return to [[Winterfell]]. Ned is disturbed that Robert still hates the long dead Rhaegar Targaryen so much. Then Ned thinks about what will happen when the king discovers that [[Catelyn Stark|Catelyn]] has taken [[Tyrion Lannister]] captive. The king may not care for the Imp, but it will hurt his pride, and [[Cersei Lannister|Cersei]] will whisper in his ear. With these thoughts, Ned decides that it might be safest if he and the girls go ahead, and the rest can follow.
 +
 
 +
After Poole leaves, Ned reflects that it will be wonderful to be back at Winterfell with his sons, but he remains angry because the kingdom is in a crisis: Robert and his council of cravens and flatterers will beggar the realm, or sell it to the Lannisters. Then there is the murder of [[Jon Arryn]]. Ned considers taking a ship back to Winterfell, even though he would prefer the [[kingsroad]], so that he can stop at [[Dragonstone]] and maybe learn the truth from [[Stannis Baratheon]].
 +
 
 +
The more he thinks about it, the more Ned guesses the truth is a secret he may not want to know. He looks again at the assassin’s dagger and wonders if it has some connection to the mystery of Arryn’s death. Could Robert be part of it? He remembers Catelyn telling him that he knew the man but the king is someone different. Ned summons Poole back and tells him to find a fast ship with a good captain, quietly but quickly; if he could find a ship tomorrow, it would be best to be on it.
 +
 
 +
[[Tomard]] announces the arrival of Littlefinger. Ned is tempted to send him away, but thinks better of it. Littlefinger informs Ned that he has managed to convince the council to offer a lordship to any man who kills Daenerys rather than hire the Faceless Men. When Ned criticizes the principle of giving titles to assassins, Littlefinger points out that he actually did Daenerys more good than Ned did; if a [[Faceless Man]] were to be sent against the girl she would be as good as buried, whereas this way some idiot will likely botch the job and put the Dothraki on their guard.
 +
 
 +
Ned is incredulous; Littlefinger supported the proposal but now expects him to believe that he was defending the girl. Littlefinger then calls Ned an enormous fool who rules like a man dancing on rotten ice. Ned insists that he has had his fill of politics. Littlefinger then says that if Ned is still in the city this evening he will take him to the [[Chataya's brothel|brothel]] his men have been searching for so ineffectually.
 +
 
 +
==Character List==
 +
{| class="wikitable" width="100%"
 +
|- valign="top"
 +
| style="width:50%;" |
 +
'''Appearing:'''
 +
{{Columns|3|
 +
*[[Ned Stark]]
 +
*[[Robert Baratheon]]
 +
*[[Varys]]
 +
*[[Renly Baratheon]]
 +
*[[Barristan Selmy]]
 +
*[[Pycelle]]
 +
*[[Petyr Baelish]]
 +
*[[Boros Blount]]
 +
*[[Vayon Poole]]
 +
*[[Tomard]]
 +
}}
 +
| style="width:50%;" |
 +
'''Mentioned:'''
 +
{{Columns|3|
 +
*[[Daenerys Targaryen]]
 +
*[[Rhaego]]
 +
*[[Viserys Targaryen]]
 +
*[[Jorah Mormont]]
 +
*[[Aegon I Targaryen]]
 +
*[[Jon Arryn]]
 +
*[[Roose Bolton]]
 +
*[[Aerys II Targaryen]]
 +
*[[Rhaegar Targaryen]]
 +
*[[Khal Drogo]]
 +
*[[Yoren]]
 +
*[[Catelyn Stark]]
 +
*[[Tyrion Lannister]]
 +
*[[Jory Cassel]]
 +
*[[Stannis Baratheon]]
 +
*[[Bran Stark]]
 +
*[[Tanda Stokeworth]]
 +
*[[Lollys Stokeworth]]
 +
*[[Cersei Lannister]]
 +
}}
 
|}
 
|}
  
== Synopsis ==
+
==Places and Terms==
 
+
{| class="wikitable" width="100%"
[[Eddard Stark|Ned]] is trying to persuade [[Robert Baratheon|Robert]] against sending men to kill [[Daenerys Targaryen]], after they learn of her pregnancy from [[Varys]]. Robert wants every [[House Targaryen|Targaryen]] dead, and gets very angry at Ned’s resistance. The other counselors agree with the King except Ser [[Barristan Selmy|Barristan]], [[Renly Baratheon|Renly]] stating that Robert should have had [[Viserys Targaryen|Viserys]] and Daenerys killed years ago, but he listened to [[Jon Arryn]]. Ned points out that [[Battle of the Trident|at the Trident]], Ser Barristan slew a dozen of Robert and Ned’s men, yet when [[Roose Bolton]] urged them to cut his throat, Robert instead absolved him and he stood Lord Commander and at the table with the small council. [[Pycelle]] says that the realm will bleed if Daenerys brings an army to [[Westeros]], so the murder of one is justified. Renly suggests that Ser [[Jorah Mormont|Jorah]] craves a pardon, so use him. But Varys suggests using poison, the [[Tears of Lys]], to which Pycelle seems to awaken from his sleepy look. Ned, disgusted, tells Robert to do it himself, then resigns from office as [[Hand of the King|Hand]], and leaves the room, overhearing Pycelle mention the [[Faceless Men]] on [[Braavos]], but [[Petyr Baelish|Littlefinger]] is appalled because they are so expensive to hire.
+
|- valign="top"
 +
| style="width:50%;" |
 +
'''Places:'''
 +
{{Columns|2|
 +
*[[barrowlands]]
 +
*[[Narrow Sea]]
 +
*[[The Trident]]
 +
*[[Vaes Dothrak]]
 +
*[[Lys]]
 +
*[[Winterfell]]
 +
*[[Braavos]]
 +
*[[Tower of the Hand]]
 +
*[[Dragonstone]]
 +
}}
 +
| style="width:50%;" |
 +
'''Terms:'''
 +
{{Columns|2|
 +
*[[Small Council]]
 +
*[[Dothraki]]
 +
*[[Kingsguard]]
 +
*[[khaleesi]]
 +
*[[Tears of Lys]]
 +
*[[Faceless Men]]
 +
}}
 +
|}
  
Ned gets to the tower, and tells [[Vayon Poole]] to make preparations to leave [[King's Landing]] and return to [[Winterfell]]. He says they must be gone soon, a fortnight is too long. But Ned doesn’t want to leave yet with so much undone, especially not discovering why Jon Arryn died. He thinks of sailing to [[Dragonstone]] to find out what Stannis knows. But if he learns the truth what then? Littlefinger arrives as Ned is thinking, and tells him that Robert will offer a lordship and land to anyone who kills Daenerys. Ned makes it known that he is returning to Winterfell, but Littlefinger tells him if he is still in King’s Landing come evening, he will take him to the elusive brothel his men have been searching for.  
+
==External links==
 +
*[http://www.tor.com/blogs/2011/07/a-read-of-ice-and-fire-a-game-of-thrones-part-17 Summary and analyses of the chapter] by Leigh Butler.
 +
*[http://towerofthehand.com/books/101/034/index.html Summary of the chapter] on Tower of the Hand.
  
 
== References and Notes ==
 
== References and Notes ==
* The synopsis was copied from AOL member vbkorik27 previously at [http://web.archive.org/web/20080228051425/members.aol.com/vbkorik27/summary/legend.html].
+
[[Category:A_Song_of_Ice_And_Fire_chapters|A Game of Thrones: Chapter 33]]
 +
[[Category:A_Song_of_Ice_And_Fire_chapters--POV_Eddard_Stark]]
 +
[[Category:Chapters which take place at the Red Keep]]
  
[[Category:A_Song_of_Ice_And_Fire_chapters|A Game of Thrones: Chapter 33]] [[Category:A_Song_of_Ice_And_Fire_chapters--POV_Eddard_Stark]]
+
[[fr:A Game of Thrones, Chapitre 34, Eddard]]
 +
[[pt:A Guerra dos Tronos - Capítulo 33]]
 +
[[ru:Игра престолов, Эддард VIII]]

Latest revision as of 21:07, 21 March 2022

Eddard VIII
A Game of Thrones chapter
AGameOfThrones.jpg
POV Eddard Stark
Place King's Landing
Page 294 (US bantam HC) US HC (Other versions)
Chapter chronology (All)
Eddard VII
Arya III  ← Eddard VIII →  Catelyn VI

Eddard IX

Ned and King Robert argue over a plot to kill Daenerys Targaryen. When the small council also sides against him, Ned resigns in protest. As Ned prepares to return to Winterfell, Littlefinger arrives with news that he has identified the brothel that Jon Arryn and Stannis Baratheon visited.

Synopsis

Robert Baratheon’s small council © FFG

Ned is trying to dissuade King Robert from sending men to kill Daenerys Targaryen, now that Varys has received reports of her pregnancy. Robert wants every Targaryen dead and grows very angry with Ned’s resistance. Ned insists that even if the report is true a lot can happen before the child is old enough to be a threat; the mother might miscarry, or the child might be born female or die in infancy. Ned also proclaims that he will only fear the Dothraki when they teach their horses to run on water.

Renly comments that it was a mistake to allow Viserys and Daenerys to live this long. Ned insists that mercy is never a mistake, pointing out that at the Battle of the Trident Ser Barristan Selmy slew a dozen friends of both Ned and Robert, yet Robert absolved him and appointed him Lord Commander of the Kingsguard. Robert insists that it is not the same; Ser Barristan was a knight of the Kingsguard. Ned counters that Daenerys is a 14-year-old girl and asks why they overthrew House Targaryen if not to end the murder of children. Robert growls that it was to put an end to Targaryens.

When Ned questions how a man who never feared Rhaegar Targaryen can tremble at the shadow of an unborn child, King Robert bellows that he has heard enough and asks for a vote. The other councilors all side with the king except for Ser Barristan who states that there is no honor in killing an enemy in his mother’s womb.

With the decision made, Robert turns to the topic of how best to carry out the assassination. Renly suggests that Ser Jorah Mormont, who craves a royal pardon, might be of use. Varys reminds them all that Ser Jorah is unlikely to risk the punishment the Dothraki would inflict on the murderer of a khaleesi. Instead, the eunuch proposes the alternative of poison, such as the Tears of Lys; Khal Drogo need never know it was not a natural death.

The mention of the Tears of Lys seems to awaken Grand Maester Pycelle from his drowsiness and Robert denounces poison as a coward’s weapon. Ned remarks on the hypocrisy of debating an honorable way to assassinate a 14-year-old and declares that Robert should do the killing himself, the honorable way among the First Men. Robert is astounded when he realizes that Ned actually means what he has just said.

Ned removes his badge of office, declaring that he thought Robert was a better man. © FFG

Ned refuses to participate further, declaring that Robert can do as he likes but that he will have no part of it. Robert declares that, as Hand, Ned will do as commanded or be replaced by a Hand who will. Ned wishes luck to his replacement and removes his badge of office, declaring that he thought Robert was a better man. As Ned marches away, the king calls after him that he will have Ned’s head on a spike if he ever sees him again. Before Ned has even left, the council resumes the discussion and Ned overhears Pycelle telling the others of a society of assassins in Braavos called the Faceless Men. Littlefinger counters that they can hire an army of sellswords for a fraction of the price.

Ned returns to the Tower of the Hand and summons Vayon Poole to discuss arrangements for their return to Winterfell. Ned is disturbed that Robert still hates the long dead Rhaegar Targaryen so much. Then Ned thinks about what will happen when the king discovers that Catelyn has taken Tyrion Lannister captive. The king may not care for the Imp, but it will hurt his pride, and Cersei will whisper in his ear. With these thoughts, Ned decides that it might be safest if he and the girls go ahead, and the rest can follow.

After Poole leaves, Ned reflects that it will be wonderful to be back at Winterfell with his sons, but he remains angry because the kingdom is in a crisis: Robert and his council of cravens and flatterers will beggar the realm, or sell it to the Lannisters. Then there is the murder of Jon Arryn. Ned considers taking a ship back to Winterfell, even though he would prefer the kingsroad, so that he can stop at Dragonstone and maybe learn the truth from Stannis Baratheon.

The more he thinks about it, the more Ned guesses the truth is a secret he may not want to know. He looks again at the assassin’s dagger and wonders if it has some connection to the mystery of Arryn’s death. Could Robert be part of it? He remembers Catelyn telling him that he knew the man but the king is someone different. Ned summons Poole back and tells him to find a fast ship with a good captain, quietly but quickly; if he could find a ship tomorrow, it would be best to be on it.

Tomard announces the arrival of Littlefinger. Ned is tempted to send him away, but thinks better of it. Littlefinger informs Ned that he has managed to convince the council to offer a lordship to any man who kills Daenerys rather than hire the Faceless Men. When Ned criticizes the principle of giving titles to assassins, Littlefinger points out that he actually did Daenerys more good than Ned did; if a Faceless Man were to be sent against the girl she would be as good as buried, whereas this way some idiot will likely botch the job and put the Dothraki on their guard.

Ned is incredulous; Littlefinger supported the proposal but now expects him to believe that he was defending the girl. Littlefinger then calls Ned an enormous fool who rules like a man dancing on rotten ice. Ned insists that he has had his fill of politics. Littlefinger then says that if Ned is still in the city this evening he will take him to the brothel his men have been searching for so ineffectually.

Character List

Appearing:

Mentioned:

Places and Terms

Places:

Terms:

External links

References and Notes