Difference between revisions of "Loras Tyrell/Theories"

From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
Jump to: navigation, search
m ("off of" → "off")
Line 5: Line 5:
 
==Potential reasons==
 
==Potential reasons==
 
*To weaken [[Cersei Lannister]]'s reign as Queen Regent, and the status of [[House Lannister]] more broadly.
 
*To weaken [[Cersei Lannister]]'s reign as Queen Regent, and the status of [[House Lannister]] more broadly.
*To free up the Redwyne fleet to deal with the [[Ironborn]] invasion of the [[Shield Islands]], as Loras initially argued.
+
*To free up the [[Redwyne fleet]] to deal with the [[taking of the Shields]] by the [[ironborn]], as Loras initially argued.
*[[Kevan Lannister]] states that Loras and his forces searched Dragonstone for dragon eggs or other priceless artifacts, but found nothing. It is possible that Loras found, if not those specific things, something else that could be used to benefit [[House Tyrell]].
+
*[[Mace Tyrell]] states that Loras's men searched Dragonstone for [[dragon egg]]s or other priceless artifacts, but found nothing. It is possible that they found, if not those specific things, something else that could be used to benefit [[House Tyrell]].
  
 
==Evidence for==
 
==Evidence for==
  
 
*As far as the reader knows, the only evidence given as to Loras's injuries is what [[Aurane Waters]] tells Cersei Lannister, and as Aurane later quickly abandons Cersei, his loyalty to her is certainly questionable.
 
*As far as the reader knows, the only evidence given as to Loras's injuries is what [[Aurane Waters]] tells Cersei Lannister, and as Aurane later quickly abandons Cersei, his loyalty to her is certainly questionable.
*In ''[[A Feast for Crows]]'', [[Myranda Royce]] tells [[Sansa Stark]] that [[Riverrun]] has been taken by the forces of the [[Iron Throne]], and that [[Dragonstone]] will soon follow. However, Waters tells Cersei that Dragonstone was taken before Riverrun.
+
*In ''[[A Feast for Crows]]'', [[Myranda Royce]] tells [[Sansa Stark]] that [[siege of Riverrun|Riverrun]] has been taken by the forces of the [[Iron Throne]], and that [[Dragonstone]] will soon follow. However, Aurane tells Cersei that Dragonstone was taken before Riverrun.
*According to Waters, during the battle Loras was first hit with a quarrel in the thigh, then one through the shoulder, then had his ribs broken by a mace, but kept fighting at the front of the assault until he was hit with boiling oil. This seems an excessive amount of injuries to sustain while continuing to fight in the vanguard of an intense assault, even for Loras.
+
*According to Aurane, during the battle Loras was first hit with a quarrel in the thigh, then one through the shoulder, then had his ribs broken by a mace, but kept fighting at the front of the assault until he was hit with boiling oil. This seems an excessive amount of injuries to sustain while continuing to fight in the vanguard of an intense assault, even for Loras.
 
*It was the belief that Loras was out of the picture that led Cersei to begin to move against [[Margaery Tyrell]], which set in motion the events of Cersei's own downfall.
 
*It was the belief that Loras was out of the picture that led Cersei to begin to move against [[Margaery Tyrell]], which set in motion the events of Cersei's own downfall.
 
*Loras's leadership during the siege resulted in the death of one thousand of the Iron Throne's soldiers. Whether they actually died or defected along with Loras, it would be a large blow to the forces of the Iron Throne and House Lannister.
 
*Loras's leadership during the siege resulted in the death of one thousand of the Iron Throne's soldiers. Whether they actually died or defected along with Loras, it would be a large blow to the forces of the Iron Throne and House Lannister.
*When taking Dragonstone, Waters says that Loras offered single combat to its commander, [[Rolland Storm]], but Storm declined. This would seem to be out of character for Storm and his belief in the Warrior. Further, Stannis only left a token force on Dragonstone, which would seem less likely to inflict such large-scale casualties on the Iron Throne's forces.
+
*When taking Dragonstone, Aurane says that Loras offered single combat to its commander, [[Rolland Storm]], but Rolland declined. This would seem to be out of character for Rolland and his belief in [[Warrior (the Seven)|the Warrior]]. Further, Stannis only left a token force on Dragonstone, which would seem less likely to inflict such large-scale casualties on the Iron Throne's forces.
*In ''[[A Dance with Dragons]]'', none of Stannis Baratheon's followers mention having lost Dragonstone, which would have been a major defeat for them.
+
*In ''[[A Dance with Dragons]]'', none of Stannis's followers mention having lost Dragonstone, which would have been a major defeat for them.
*Kevan Lannister notes that, despite his injuries, Loras has been personally searching Dragonstone. This would seem rather difficult to do for someone who had sustained the injuries described by Waters.
+
*Mace Tyrell states that his son's men have found nothing of value on Dragonstone. Kevan Lannister is skeptical of their thoroughness, as he distrusts Dragonstone's Valyrian origin and because he thinks Loras is too injured to lead a proper search.
*According to ''[[The Winds of Winter]]'', Waters has apparently established himself as a pirate chief in the [[Stepstones]] off [[Dorne]]. If Waters and Loras were conspiring, this would allow Waters to harass the forces of [[House Martell]], the longtime enemies of House Tyrell.
+
*According to ''[[The Winds of Winter]]'', a new pirate king—possibly Aurane—has established himself on [[Torturer's Deep]]. If Aurane and Loras were conspiring, this would allow Aurane to harass the forces of [[House Martell]], the longtime enemies of House Tyrell.
  
 
==Evidence against==
 
==Evidence against==
 
*It would presumably be difficult to keep the non-capture of Dragonstone a secret for long, given how many ships pass through [[Blackwater Bay]] en route to [[King's Landing]].
 
*It would presumably be difficult to keep the non-capture of Dragonstone a secret for long, given how many ships pass through [[Blackwater Bay]] en route to [[King's Landing]].
*If the Siege of Dragonstone was a complete fabrication, it would require House Tyrell to conspire with Stannis Baratheon, who is known to dislike House Tyrell for their part in the [[Siege of Storm's End]]. Additionally, Stannis's claim to the throne would not benefit Margaery's desire to be Queen, which is contingent on her marriage to [[Tommen Baratheon]] and his status as King.
+
*If the siege of Dragonstone is a complete fabrication, it would require House Tyrell to conspire with Stannis Baratheon, who is known to dislike House Tyrell for their part in the [[siege of Storm's End]]. Additionally, Stannis's claim to the throne would not benefit Margaery's desire to be Queen, which is contingent on her marriage to [[Tommen Baratheon]] and his status as King.
  
 
[[Category:Theories]]
 
[[Category:Theories]]

Revision as of 18:38, 16 March 2020

 Theories may be removed if ... 
  1. Stated as questions or possibilities.
  2. More appropriate for another article.
  3. Illogical or previously disproven.
  4. Proven by canon source, and moved to main page.
  5. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments.
  6. Responding to another theory (use discussion page instead).
  • This does not include responses that are also standalone theories.
  • Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response.

According to this theory, Loras Tyrell's severe injuries at the Siege of Dragonstone are not as they seem.

Potential reasons

Evidence for

  • As far as the reader knows, the only evidence given as to Loras's injuries is what Aurane Waters tells Cersei Lannister, and as Aurane later quickly abandons Cersei, his loyalty to her is certainly questionable.
  • In A Feast for Crows, Myranda Royce tells Sansa Stark that Riverrun has been taken by the forces of the Iron Throne, and that Dragonstone will soon follow. However, Aurane tells Cersei that Dragonstone was taken before Riverrun.
  • According to Aurane, during the battle Loras was first hit with a quarrel in the thigh, then one through the shoulder, then had his ribs broken by a mace, but kept fighting at the front of the assault until he was hit with boiling oil. This seems an excessive amount of injuries to sustain while continuing to fight in the vanguard of an intense assault, even for Loras.
  • It was the belief that Loras was out of the picture that led Cersei to begin to move against Margaery Tyrell, which set in motion the events of Cersei's own downfall.
  • Loras's leadership during the siege resulted in the death of one thousand of the Iron Throne's soldiers. Whether they actually died or defected along with Loras, it would be a large blow to the forces of the Iron Throne and House Lannister.
  • When taking Dragonstone, Aurane says that Loras offered single combat to its commander, Rolland Storm, but Rolland declined. This would seem to be out of character for Rolland and his belief in the Warrior. Further, Stannis only left a token force on Dragonstone, which would seem less likely to inflict such large-scale casualties on the Iron Throne's forces.
  • In A Dance with Dragons, none of Stannis's followers mention having lost Dragonstone, which would have been a major defeat for them.
  • Mace Tyrell states that his son's men have found nothing of value on Dragonstone. Kevan Lannister is skeptical of their thoroughness, as he distrusts Dragonstone's Valyrian origin and because he thinks Loras is too injured to lead a proper search.
  • According to The Winds of Winter, a new pirate king—possibly Aurane—has established himself on Torturer's Deep. If Aurane and Loras were conspiring, this would allow Aurane to harass the forces of House Martell, the longtime enemies of House Tyrell.

Evidence against

  • It would presumably be difficult to keep the non-capture of Dragonstone a secret for long, given how many ships pass through Blackwater Bay en route to King's Landing.
  • If the siege of Dragonstone is a complete fabrication, it would require House Tyrell to conspire with Stannis Baratheon, who is known to dislike House Tyrell for their part in the siege of Storm's End. Additionally, Stannis's claim to the throne would not benefit Margaery's desire to be Queen, which is contingent on her marriage to Tommen Baratheon and his status as King.