Difference between revisions of "Help: Referencing and Canon"

From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
Jump to: navigation, search
m
(touch up)
 
(17 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Our intention is to provide reliable information about the world of Song of Ice and fire. To this end, the information in articles should provide as accurate a description of the background, events, characters etc. The information should also be objective, using facts that can be Verified independently by other readers. For that effect we have References allow editors to provide sources for statements in articles based on a reliable source.
+
Our intention is to provide reliable information about the world of ''[[A Song of Ice and Fire]]''. To this end, the information in articles should provide an accurate description of the background, events, characters, etc. The information should also be objective, using facts that can be verified independently by other readers. Referencing the information allows editors to provide sources for statements in articles based on a reliable source.
  
 
__TOC__
 
__TOC__
 +
==Canon==
 +
'''Canon''' is a term used to denote officially accepted material within fictional work, for the purpose of creating an authentic and consistent corpus; i.e. characters, locations, events and settings details that are considered to be genuine (or "official"). The following policy outlines what is considered part of the canon and what is not on this wiki.
  
==References==
+
The canon is broken down into two levels: '''Canon''' and '''Semi-canon'''. Together, these two levels form the overall ''[[A Song of Ice and Fire]]'' continuity. Each ascending level overrides the lower ones; for example, [[Mago]] is killed in the first season of the television series ''[[Game of Thrones]]'', but he still lives in the novels as of ''[[A Dance with Dragons]]''. Therefore, he is considered officially alive in the overall story.
To add a reference in the simplest way, place your source/explanation between the <code><nowiki><ref>...</ref></nowiki></code> tags, at the appropriate place in the article text, for example:
 
  
<code><nowiki><ref>[http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Month/2008/07/ Spanish Q&A] - July 2008</ref></nowiki></code>
+
*'''Canon''': Primary canon, consisting of works written by or with primary involvement of [[George R. R. Martin]], such as the novels of ''A Song of Ice and Fire'', the ''Dunk and Egg'' novellas, and ''[[The World of Ice & Fire]]'' world book, but excluding his TV show scripts which are written to the TV show canon as established by its own showrunners, and writings expressly placed outside of canon such as his ''Cage Match 2010'' write-ups. Martin has indicated that the world book is "authoritative" and the novels are "supreme canon".<ref>[[So Spake Martin]]: [http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Entry/Stockholm_and_Archipelacon_Report Stockholm and Archipelacon Report], June 28, 2015</ref> Regarding inconsistencies between published works, Martin said, "The novels always trump."<ref>[[Not A Blog]]: [http://grrm.livejournal.com/429752.html?thread=21745080#t21745080 Wars, Woes, Work], June 10, 2015</ref>
  
<code><nowiki><ref>[[A Game of Thrones]], [[A Game of Thrones-Chapter 9|Chapter 9]], Tyrion</ref></nowiki></code>
+
*'''Semi-Canon''': Secondary canon, consisting of information verified as having been given by Martin outside of the published works. This includes information given to officially licensed third parties, such as the television show and roleplaying games, and information given through [[So Spake Martin]], [[Not A Blog]], correspondence with fans, readings and signings, statements in interviews, samples or excerpts from unpublished manuscripts, etc. ''[[A Song of Ice and Fire Campaign Guide]]'' from 2010, for instance, has been considered [http://grrm.livejournal.com/157114.html?thread=10294714#t10294714 "changeable canon"], and has been contradicted by newer publications, such as ''The World of Ice and Fire'' from 2014. The reference app, ''[[A World of Ice and Fire]]'', is also considered semi-canon.<ref>Ran in [http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/34958-the-asoiaf-wiki-thread/?p=7061843 A Forum of Ice and Fire], June 05, 2015</ref> Please note the "verified" qualifier -- origin with Martin must be an established fact, not simply assumed, and must clearly refer to his series as opposed to the canon of any derivative works. If two pieces of secondary canon appear to contradict each other, it should generally be assumed that the most recently given information is correct.
 +
 +
The key point in determining canon is that it must be from George R. R. Martin. Any content that cannot be determined as having originated with or been expressly regarded as canon by Martin cannot in itself be considered canon.
  
This would appear on the page as follows: <ref>[http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Month/2008/07/ Spanish Q&A] - July 2008</ref> and <ref>[[A Game of Thrones]], [[A Game of Thrones-Chapter 9|Chapter 9]], Tyrion</ref>.
+
==Referencing==
The references appears as links that links to a detailed explanation further down the page.
+
Being able to provide verifiable source references increase the reliability of your wiki and allow others to check and extend your work. For sources from the novels, it is preferred that an editor makes use of the [[Template:Ref|Ref Template]]. For example:
 +
<code><nowiki>{{Ref|aGoT|9}}</nowiki></code>
  
 +
automatically generates the following:<br>
 +
''[[A Game of Thrones]]'', [[A Game of Thrones-Chapter 9|Chapter 9]], Tyrion I
  
For sources from the novels, you can use the [[Template:Ref|Ref]] [[Help:Templates|Template]], for example:
+
The Ref Template groups references to the same source, avoiding an excessive long reference list when one reference is used multiple times on the same page, making it the preferred option for sourcing. In addition, any changes within the template will immediately reflect on all pages on which it is used, instead of having to change them all manually.
<code><nowiki>{{Ref|aGoT|9}}</nowiki></code>{{Ref|aGoT|9}}
 
  
Which results in the same reference, see the [[Template:Ref]] page for further details.
+
Other sources (e.g., [[So Spake Martin]], [[Not a Blog]], posts from the forum) can be placed by simply placing your source between the <code><nowiki><ref>...</ref></nowiki></code> tags, at the appropriate place in the article text, for example:
  
 +
<code><nowiki><ref>asoiaf.westeros.org: Small Questions v. 10105 [https://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/137792-small-questions-v-10105/&do=findComment&comment=8291361 TMK timeline (22 January, 2019)]</ref></nowiki></code>
  
To make the list of references appear on the page, as you can see below, add the <code><nowiki>{{References}}</nowiki></code> tag to the page, for example:
+
<code><nowiki><ref>[[So Spake Martin]]: [http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Entry/Highgarden_and_the_Rock Highgarden and the Rock (January 28, 1999)]</ref></nowiki></code>
<pre>==References and Notes==
 
{{References}}</pre>
 
  
This only needed to be done once, by the first editor to add references. For further infomariton on this template see its [[Template:References|documentation page]]
+
These would appear in the reference list as follows:
 +
asoiaf.westeros.org: Small Questions v. 10105 [https://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/137792-small-questions-v-10105/&do=findComment&comment=8291361 TMK timeline (22 January, 2019)]</ref>
  
 +
[[So Spake Martin]]: [http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Entry/Highgarden_and_the_Rock Highgarden and the Rock (January 28, 1999)]
  
==Canon==
+
The references in the text appear as superscript links that link to a detailed list at the bottom of the page. To make the list of references appear on the page, as you can see below, add the <code><nowiki>{{References}}</nowiki></code> tag to the page below the "References" subheader, for example:
{{Stub|I believe this is only the first draft, see [http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/57950-canon/page__pid__2723234 discussion], --[[User:Mordin999|Mor]] 04:11, 26 October 2011 (UTC)}}
 
  
'''Canon''' is a term used to denote officially accepted material within fictional work, for the purpose of creating an authentic and consistent corpus. The policy below should help clarify what is considered part of the canon on this wiki.
+
<pre>==References==
 +
{{References}}</pre>
  
The Canon is broken down into three levels: '''M''', '''T''', and '''D'''. Together, these three levels form the overall ''[[A Song of Ice and Fire]]'' continuity. Each ascending level overrides the lower ones; for example, in the television series [[Mago]] is killed, but he still lives in the novels. Therefore, he is considered officially alive in the overall story.
+
This only needs to be done once, by the first editor to add references. For further information on this template see its [[Template:References|documentation page]]
  
*'''M-Canon''' or ''Martin-Canon'' is content created by series author [[George R. R. Martin]]. This includes all novels, shorts, and published writings within the series; unpublished personal writings; fan and media correspondence, and the like. Anything written by Martin is officially correct within the series. The only way that M-Canon can be outdated or retconned is if Martin writes new content that overrides the later.
+
==References==
 
+
{{References}}
*'''T-Canon''' or ''Television Canon'' is content that is seen or created for the HBO television series [[Game of Thrones]]. Content seen in the series that is not directly contradictory to M-Canon content is considered officially correct within the series. However, any changes or alterations within the series are overridden by M-Canon ''(for example character ages, or unwritten deaths seen in the show)''.
 
 
 
*'''D-Canon''' or ''Derived Canon'' is content that is seen within [[Derived works|officially licensed products]] based on the series, such as games, comics, or companion books. D-Canon is considered officially true within the series unless it is directly contradictory or overridden by T- or M-Canon. Examples include more in-depth background on minor characters seen in the roleplaying games, or artwork in companion books showcasing characters that follows any written details about them.
 
 
 
==What is not considered a valid source, and why?==
 
* Fan fiction of any kind (this includes [[w:Canon_(fiction)#Fanon|fanon]]).
 
  
  
 
{{WikiHelpNav}}
 
{{WikiHelpNav}}
==References and Notes==
 
{{References}}
 
  
 
[[Category:Help]]
 
[[Category:Help]]

Latest revision as of 17:26, 24 January 2019

Our intention is to provide reliable information about the world of A Song of Ice and Fire. To this end, the information in articles should provide an accurate description of the background, events, characters, etc. The information should also be objective, using facts that can be verified independently by other readers. Referencing the information allows editors to provide sources for statements in articles based on a reliable source.

Canon

Canon is a term used to denote officially accepted material within fictional work, for the purpose of creating an authentic and consistent corpus; i.e. characters, locations, events and settings details that are considered to be genuine (or "official"). The following policy outlines what is considered part of the canon and what is not on this wiki.

The canon is broken down into two levels: Canon and Semi-canon. Together, these two levels form the overall A Song of Ice and Fire continuity. Each ascending level overrides the lower ones; for example, Mago is killed in the first season of the television series Game of Thrones, but he still lives in the novels as of A Dance with Dragons. Therefore, he is considered officially alive in the overall story.

  • Canon: Primary canon, consisting of works written by or with primary involvement of George R. R. Martin, such as the novels of A Song of Ice and Fire, the Dunk and Egg novellas, and The World of Ice & Fire world book, but excluding his TV show scripts which are written to the TV show canon as established by its own showrunners, and writings expressly placed outside of canon such as his Cage Match 2010 write-ups. Martin has indicated that the world book is "authoritative" and the novels are "supreme canon".[1] Regarding inconsistencies between published works, Martin said, "The novels always trump."[2]
  • Semi-Canon: Secondary canon, consisting of information verified as having been given by Martin outside of the published works. This includes information given to officially licensed third parties, such as the television show and roleplaying games, and information given through So Spake Martin, Not A Blog, correspondence with fans, readings and signings, statements in interviews, samples or excerpts from unpublished manuscripts, etc. A Song of Ice and Fire Campaign Guide from 2010, for instance, has been considered "changeable canon", and has been contradicted by newer publications, such as The World of Ice and Fire from 2014. The reference app, A World of Ice and Fire, is also considered semi-canon.[3] Please note the "verified" qualifier -- origin with Martin must be an established fact, not simply assumed, and must clearly refer to his series as opposed to the canon of any derivative works. If two pieces of secondary canon appear to contradict each other, it should generally be assumed that the most recently given information is correct.

The key point in determining canon is that it must be from George R. R. Martin. Any content that cannot be determined as having originated with or been expressly regarded as canon by Martin cannot in itself be considered canon.

Referencing

Being able to provide verifiable source references increase the reliability of your wiki and allow others to check and extend your work. For sources from the novels, it is preferred that an editor makes use of the Ref Template. For example:

{{Ref|aGoT|9}}

automatically generates the following:

A Game of Thrones, Chapter 9, Tyrion I

The Ref Template groups references to the same source, avoiding an excessive long reference list when one reference is used multiple times on the same page, making it the preferred option for sourcing. In addition, any changes within the template will immediately reflect on all pages on which it is used, instead of having to change them all manually.

Other sources (e.g., So Spake Martin, Not a Blog, posts from the forum) can be placed by simply placing your source between the <ref>...</ref> tags, at the appropriate place in the article text, for example:

<ref>asoiaf.westeros.org: Small Questions v. 10105 [https://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/137792-small-questions-v-10105/&do=findComment&comment=8291361 TMK timeline (22 January, 2019)]</ref>

<ref>[[So Spake Martin]]: [http://www.westeros.org/Citadel/SSM/Entry/Highgarden_and_the_Rock Highgarden and the Rock (January 28, 1999)]</ref>

These would appear in the reference list as follows:

asoiaf.westeros.org: Small Questions v. 10105 TMK timeline (22 January, 2019)</ref>
So Spake Martin: Highgarden and the Rock (January 28, 1999)

The references in the text appear as superscript links that link to a detailed list at the bottom of the page. To make the list of references appear on the page, as you can see below, add the {{References}} tag to the page below the "References" subheader, for example:

==References==
{{References}}

This only needs to be done once, by the first editor to add references. For further information on this template see its documentation page

References